Which is better for the dishwasher: tablets or powder - how to make the right choice

The essence of the means

To ensure that your machine lasts for many years, it is not enough to use only detergent. It is necessary to add several different components that will help you get the job done faster and better. For this, additional funds are needed.

For normal operation of the unit, at least 3 components are required:

1. Special salt. This component is required to soften hard water. Even with installed filters, tap water contains a lot of harmful impurities, which eventually become limescale on the walls of mechanisms and rubber hoses. This leads to rapid breakdown of the dishwasher.
2. Powder. This component is directly a detergent and is needed to clean dishes from grease and various contaminants.
3. Rinse aid. Tap water cannot completely remove detergent and special softening salt. To do this, you need a rinse aid that will remove chemical residues and give the dishes a glossy shine.

All 3 components are important. Without salt, the unit will “cover itself” after just six months of active use; without rinse aid, detergent will remain on the plates. Therefore, manufacturers produce various compositions for units.

Powders

First, powder products appeared on the market. These are loose mixtures of uniform consistency or with washing granules.

Also, a modern powder may contain so-called enzymes for better breakdown of fatty residues, soda for water softening, fragrances or oxygen bleach. Also, to improve the quality of washing, chlorine or phosphates are added to powder mixtures.

The undeniable advantage of powders is their budget cost. Even if you purchase all 3 required components (salt, detergent and rinse aid), it will still be quite cheap, and the mixtures will last for a long time.

Such formulations are easy to dose, but not too zealous housewives sometimes load more substance into the dishwasher, which reveals the disadvantages of powder preparations:

• Stains remain on the dishes as a result of an incorrect balance of substances;
• The drugs require certain storage conditions; high humidity in the room causes the products to stick together.
• Breakdowns and leaks due to excessive foaming.

In addition, to create the 3-in-1 effect, you need to buy several different mixtures. In this case, it is better to purchase the compositions from one manufacturer, which can be unreasonably expensive. It is not recommended to mix powders from different manufacturers.

To solve these problems, manufacturers have offered the consumer an improved tablet form of mixtures for dishwashers.

Pills

This form of mixtures for aggregates is gaining increasing popularity, if only simply due to its greater functionality. As a rule, 1 tablet combines several powders at once.

The product is produced in the form of multi-colored tablets, and each shade gives an idea of ​​a specific function. The most common are “3 in 1” capsules, although “5 in 1” and “8 in 1” tablets are now available. The following substances act as additional components in such products:

1. Means for protecting the machine from scale.
2. Protective substances for the dishes themselves.
3. Additives for glass shine.
4. Antimicrobial components.
5. Catalysts for removing complex contaminants in cold water.

In stores you can find tablets containing up to 10 additional ingredients. Of course, the composition is reflected in the cost of the tablet substance.

Capsules for dishwashers have many advantages, the main one of which is accurate dosage. The tablet already contains all the components for washing in the required proportions.

Simply load the product into the special compartment and run the dishwasher cycle. The unit will do the rest itself. And thanks to the “all in 1” options, you can significantly extend the life of the car.

Despite the ease of use and obvious advantages, there are also disadvantages. First of all, higher cost. However, everything is relative here: you can find drugs from unknown manufacturers.

Also, some briquettes do not dissolve very well in water; therefore, with a short dishwashing cycle, the active substances simply do not have time to act.

Environmentally friendly drugs

When washing, the surface of the dishes comes into contact with household chemicals, so it is important to monitor the composition of the preparations.

Despite the fact that dishwashing detergents already contain a minimal amount of hazardous components, there are also environmentally friendly formulations. They are produced both in the form of powders and tablets.

Such mixtures are made on the basis of plant extracts, they do not contain fragrances or additional chemicals. To improve the quality of washing, manufacturers add abrasives.

Such dishwashing compounds should be purchased by allergy sufferers and families with small children. The drugs guarantee complete safety, but it is necessary to take into account that they are much more expensive.

Source: https://nyamkin.ru/advice/tabletki-ili-poroshok-dlya-posudomoechnoy-mashiny-chto-luchshe

Main components of dishwasher detergents

For productive operation of any dishwasher, three components are required: special salt, powder and rinse aid. Salt softens the tap water entering the machine, making the powder foam better. Rinse aid removes traces of powder and adds shine to dishes. All dishwasher models are equipped with separate compartments for these components.

For ease of use of detergents, manufacturers have combined three components into one tablet. Each such tablet already contains at least three main components. In addition, there are “5 in 1”, “6 in 1” and even “8 in 1” capsules on sale. They may contain dishwasher cleaners, flavorings and other additives. It could even be enzymes that allow you to wash away burnt fat.

Which is better for the dishwasher: tablets or powder - let’s compare the composition

The first thing a consumer pays attention to is the price, but we believe that the first factor of choice should be the composition of the product. That is why we will compare what is included in powdered, liquid and tablet dishwasher detergents.

The main component of any product, including powder, is surfactants, which break down stains on dishes. In addition to this substance, the powder includes:

• oxygen bleach;
• enzymes that improve the breakdown of stubborn stains;
• water softening soda;
• subtilisin, which breaks down protein foods;
• sometimes phosphates;
• preservatives;
• chlorine;
• fragrances to give a pleasant aroma.

This composition may differ in the concentration of substances from different manufacturers, and some substances may be completely absent. The fewer components in the detergent, the absence of chlorine, phosphates and enzymes, the more environmentally friendly it is.

But the absence of strong chemicals can affect the quality of dishwashing. Therefore, some powders wash dishes better, others worse.

Dishwasher tablets have a similar chemical composition. However, tablets with multifunctional action, for example, 3 in 1 or 5 in 1, contain, in addition to the above substances, also agents that make dishes shine.

Thanks to them, there are no drips or streaks. In addition, one of the layers of the tablet is salt, which must be added to the dishwasher to soften the water and prevent scale formation.

As for gels, they also contain all the same components, only in a viscous liquid state. Rinsing agents can be added to gels, as well as to tablets.

The main difference between the gel and other products is the absence of abrasive components. Dense particles of powder or tablets may not dissolve, but this does not happen with the gel.

So, in terms of composition, tablets are more different from all products, since they immediately contain dishwasher salt and rinse aid. But in terms of environmental friendliness, they can all be different. There are IVF products among powders, as well as among gels and tablets. Here everything will depend on the manufacturer.

Advantages and disadvantages

Let's consider other features of detergents, highlighting their pros and cons. So, the benefits of tablet products on the face:

• they include all the necessary components, there is no need to additionally take salt and rinse aid;
• they are dosed in such a way that it is enough to put one tablet on one sink;
• each tablet has individual packaging, which prevents the release of substances into the environment during storage;
• have a variety of packaging of 20, 40 and even 120 pieces.

However, consumers are often deterred from purchasing this product by its disadvantages:

• high price, especially for tablets from well-known manufacturers. But if you compare it with the amount you have to spend on three products purchased separately, the difference is small;
• not all tablets dissolve equally well;
• they often contain phosphates, which many experts say are harmful;
• if necessary, reduce the dosage of the drug; not all tablets break easily;
• Not all dishwashers have a tablet compartment.

Despite the convenience of using tablets for PMM, powders and gels also have their advantages:

• Powdered products are cheaper. Even if you buy salt, rinse aid and gel (powder) separately, they will last longer than tablets bought with the same money;
• the powder is universal, dissolves faster than a tablet and is suitable for any dishwasher;
• With powder, you can save on salt by adding it not every wash, especially if you have a region with soft water.

As for the disadvantages, powders also have many of them:

• better washing results can be achieved if you use all the products from one manufacturer, which is not always easy to do;
• when poured into a tray, the powder generates dust, releasing harmful substances into the air;
• it is not so convenient to store it, especially in cardboard packaging, as it can spill;
• you need to select the dosage, if you overdo it with the powder, too much foam will form in the machine, and this can lead to equipment breakdown.

Users' opinions

1. Elvira, Moscow. I take Sun Classik tablets, they are inexpensive and work much better than Finish powder. Another plus is that they are convenient to use, and I can save a lot of money, because I take a huge package of 105 pieces. I won’t praise it, try it yourself and see for yourself. After I started using these pills, I gave all the other products to my friends.
2. Oksana, Moscow. My favorite is the Feed Back tablet. They dissolve well, wash cleanly, are inexpensive and can be cut in half. These tablets are made in Italy and are sold in packages of 15, 30 and 60 pieces. I recommend!
3. Yana, Naryan-Mar. I have a narrow dishwasher, so I don’t use tablets, since they contain a very large dosage of detergent. I prefer the powder, since you can choose the dose to suit yourself. Lately I have been using Finish brand powders, although other products have satisfied me with the quality. Tablets are always more expensive, so by buying powder, I also save a lot.
4. Ekaterina, Moscow. I have nothing against powder, but I don’t use it because it’s inconvenient. At first, when we first purchased the dishwasher, I didn’t know an alternative to the powder, but quite often when I poured it into the tray, I spilled it on the floor. It’s much more convenient with tablets and capsules, and they work no worse, in some ways even better. From my point of view, powder is a thing of the past!
5. Marina, Yekaterinburg. I don’t like powders because they are ineffective and leave streaks, but I also don’t buy tablets because they are expensive. The best option is Finish gel. It cleans dishes better than anyone else and leaves no streaks or chemical smell at all. I recommend it to all my friends!
6. Polina, St. Petersburg. Pills, pills and more pills, there is no better remedy. I use Finish tablets, but a little earlier I tried BioMio dishwasher tablets, they are also very good. Any dishes sparkle clean, there have never been any misfires during washing. Five points!

So, how many people, so many opinions. It is difficult to answer this question unambiguously; there are too many factors. Until you try each of the remedies yourself, you will not decide for yourself which is better.

The main thing is, don’t forget to read the instructions for the equipment, look at what the manufacturer recommends, maybe tablets are not your option at all.

Source: https://mashmaster.ru/chto-luchshe-dlya-posudomojki-poroshok-ili-tabletki/

Which is better for the dishwasher: powder or tablets?

There is no clear answer. The device doesn’t care what they put in it, but each housewife has her own preferences. When comparing dishwasher detergents, it is logical to base it on the number and type of utensils that are washed most often. Look at the table:

The conclusion is this: if you wash lightly soiled plates, mugs, small utensils, or in general the dishes get a little dirty, it is more profitable to use powder or gel. But if you have to wash pots and pans frequently, tablets will come in handy.

There is an exception. Tablet products are not suitable for owners of small desktop PMMs. Typically, 1 cube is designed to wash 10-12 sets of dishes, and the volume of the hopper of a compact appliance is smaller. It is uneconomical to use tablets - prefer powder or gel. Or divide the cube into halves.

Which brand of dishwasher detergent is best to choose?

The dishwasher is designed for effective but gentle cleaning of cutlery made from various, even the most fragile, materials.

And to make her work easier, to protect the body and parts from hard water and scale, different manufacturers offer special forms of cleaning products. First you need to identify a reliable and time-tested brand for yourself. The following companies occupy leading positions in the current ranking:

• Somat is a German brand of dishwashing products that has gained popularity since 1962. Lines of detergent products are presented in the form of powders, gels, rinses, tablets and salts. Effective components in the composition help remove the most difficult stains.
• BioMio is a trademark from Russia, which belongs to. Developing Eco chemistry, it appeared on the market in 2013. Among all the products from various domestic developers, only this one has the “Leaf of Life” certificate, confirming its safety and effectiveness.
• Clean&Fresh is a trademark owned by the Russian company Lotta. A distinctive feature of household chemicals with this name is the best price solution in Russia. Work experience exceeds 16 years. The main part of the range is environmentally friendly, hypoallergenic, precisely dosed cleaning products.
• Bravix is ​​a trademark owned by the German company Dreco Werke Wasch und Körperpflegemittel GmbH. The products guarantee excellent cleaning abilities, increased efficiency, affordable prices, environmental friendliness and hypoallergenicity. Each product is delivered to the market in practical Euro packaging.
• Topperr is a signature brand owned by the group. This is one of the leading domestic companies producing cleaning products for home care and accessories for household appliances. Products with this name appeared on the Russian market back in 2003.
• Paclan was originally a large German company that began operations in 1977. Then it merged with the British company Poly-Lina, and is now owned by CeDo. Under this brand you can see various household goods for the home and industry.
• Finish is a brand owned by the large RB company since 1953. As soon as dishwashers went on sale, related products for it with the same name immediately appeared from a British-Dutch company. Today, the products are very popular in more than 40 countries around the world.
• Lion is a Japanese company that works closely with South Korea. Initially, these were original household chemicals for the domestic market of these countries. But very soon it began to be supplied to Europe and the countries of the former CIS. The history of the brand goes back over 100 years. It is the No. 1 oral care product in Japan.
• Fairy is a trademark owned by the large European company Procter and Gamble (Dawn in America). The brand was founded in 1929, when liquid soap with a unique formula that could float on water first appeared under this name. The main part of the products are dishwashing detergents, widely known throughout Europe.

Source: https://vyborexperta.ru/bytovaya-tekhnika/luchshie-sredstva-dlja-posudomoechnoj-mashiny/

How to make the right choice?

There is no clear answer to the question: which is better - tablets or powder? Housewives usually choose a detergent according to their taste, listening to the manufacturers' recommendations.

According to recent studies, tablets come first in the ranking of drugs for dishwashers. Despite the high price, they have earned the sympathy of buyers for their ease of use and efficiency.

However, in some cases it is better to prefer dry cleaning mixtures. It is advisable to use them in the “Partial load” mode, as well as in the case of quick dishwashing.

To ensure that the cleaning quality does not disappoint PMM users, it is important to follow simple rules when washing dishes.

1. Before using any product, you should carefully study the instructions for use of the drug.
2. If you plan to use detergents in combination, it is advisable to purchase products from the same company to achieve better results.
3. It is strictly forbidden to use detergents for manual dishwashing in the dishwasher, as they tend to generate increased foaming. Excess foam leads to leaks, and, as a result, to breakdowns of the unit. When choosing a dishwashing mode with a temperature of 40-50 ᵒC, it is better to use tablets with enzymes. The capsules will carefully wash dishes and cutlery.
4. Products containing acids and alkalis do an excellent job of removing stains, but such preparations have a bleaching effect. This property must be taken into account when washing dishes with painted elements.
5. On an industrial scale, detergents are used that cannot be used in household dishwashers.

The best products for your dishwasher

• Calgonit Finish gel effectively washes dishes and adds shine and squeak to items. It is economical, rational in consumption and easy to use. The product lasts up to five months when used every day;
• Minel Total tablets work at any water temperature and prevent limescale and scale. Instantly break down fat, disinfect dishes and completely wash out. Products include rinse aid and salt;
• BioMio BIO-Total is an environmentally friendly and safe 7 in 1 complex product. This is a good and effective tablet containing eucalyptus essential oil, which gives a fresh, light aroma and has a gentle effect during the washing process. Does not require the use of rinse aid or salt. Dissolves quickly and does not leave streaks. Effectively cleans glass, steel and eliminates unpleasant odors;
• Claro powder has a triple cleansing effect and does not require the use of rinse aid or pre-soaking. As a result, the dishes remain clean, shiny and streak-free. This powder contains salt to soften water and elements that protect against scale. Economically used;
• Finish Quantum tablets are the best product according to many customer reviews. It effectively copes with grease, old and difficult stains, and dried food residues. 100% washable with water, leaves no marks or streaks;
• Frosch Soda is an environmentally friendly and safe three-layer tablet without phosphates and harmful chemical additives, therefore it does not cause an allergic reaction. They have an intense and immediate effect, preventing the formation of limescale. Contains natural soda, salt and rinse aid;
• Eonit is an affordable product in the form of tablets at a low price without surfactants or harmful substances. It effectively removes grease, complex stains, coffee and tea deposits. Includes rinse aid and salt, cleans dishes to a shine and protects items from tarnishing, darkening and loss of color;
• Feed Back is a tablet product that removes fat and food residues, but does not always cope with coffee residue. It is distinguished by its environmentally friendly, safe composition, affordable price and easy use.

When choosing a detergent, consider the type and class of the dishwasher and the type of dishware materials. Do not use classic liquids and gels for manual dishwashing! Otherwise the machine will break. And what dishes can be safely washed in the dishwasher, read the link.

conclusions

It is difficult to definitively answer the question of which dishwashing detergent is better than the rest. It all depends on the composition of the detergent, the quality of the dishes and the cleaning regime.

To keep your cutlery and kitchen utensils sparkling clean, and to ensure that your dishwasher serves you faithfully for a long time, you need to strictly follow the instructions.

When washing, it is best to use products from well-known brands that value their reputation and are responsible for the quality of their products.

Source: https://ghard.ru/chto-vybrat-dlya-posudomoechnoj-mashiny-poroshok-ili-tabletki-sravnitelnyj-rejting-moyushhix-preparatov